09-06-2017 02:12 PM - edited 09-07-2017 03:15 PM
I have been thinking of homeschooling my 3-year-old Daniel and was looking into the Montessori curriculum to do it. I even bought some Montessori games and puzzles for teaching him. But I happened to read some negative comments on 'Montessori schooling'. It was said that the 'Montessori kids' will have difficulty in a reception class and will struggle to settle in as they just aren't used to having to stick to the strict routines of a school like sitting at a desk for ages at a time or do set activities at the same time as everyone else. Should I reconsider my decision and send him to a traditional school instead? Please let me know your thoughts on this.
09-08-2017 08:01 PM - edited 09-08-2017 08:12 PM
Hi @Powell-Karen . Thanks for sharing your issue with us . When our little ones are toddlers we worry about the best route for them in terms of education and pyscho-social development. It can be a difficult decision to make .
You say that Daniel is 3 . Are you thinking if homeschooling all though primary years ? Or do you want yo start with Montessori, and then home school him with a regular curriculum ? I'm a bit confused .
ALL alternative curriculums have their negative press . Don't buy into it . If you feel instinctively that Montessori is right for your boy then go ahead with it . Children learn by doing and if a more physical task oriented style of learning is right for him in your opinion them go head with it . All education styles have their pros and cons . The bottom line is he is happy and thriving and learning .
I sent my children to a Steiner curriculum in a mainstream school . While Steiner is a fabulous philosophy and was great for my girl my son had a LD and it was not picked up in Steiner because they did not hone in on the 3 R s soon enough . When we discovered he had a processing problem I moved him to mainstream , so his could get more intensive 3 Rs. This was only because of his need to work that particular "muscle " a bit more than he average child
Steiner is one of the best educational styles around for kids who are typical average learners and above average . It's active , its creative and imaginative as well as cerebral and academic . It teaches a child to be resourceful and literal thinkers . It's a jam packed curriculum which incorporates the development of the heart head and mind . Children learn to sew , knit , cook , play music , use their bodies in movement as well as 3Rs . It's time and pace structured so children learn specific things as specific developmental stage eg they start learning to read at 7 when their teeth fall out .
Researching as much as you can about Montessori in your area is a must , and then... go with your gut .
Best of luck ! I am sure you will make the best choice for your little boy .
09-09-2017 12:58 PM
Hi I teach in a Montessori school in Perth, which sticks pretty closely to the M curriculum through ages 3-9. After that we tend to call ourselves Montessori inspired as the demands of the state high school curriculum mean we have to change the approach. NK most Montessori schools would ask you to do a couple pre entry classroom observations before you enroll so you can see exactly what goes on in a classroom. I feel the Montessori philosophy is a highly resourced and guided way of learning. Children do have to work with a partner sometimes, they do sit and listen to stories, they do whole class activities. So, my suggestion is to do as many observations as you want. No true Montessori school should object to that. We have a requirement of all our parents that do an observation at least twice a year, so it's not unusual for me to have a parent in my high school classroom!
Good luck with your decision.
09:00AM to 5:00PM Mon - Fri
We are not a counselling or crisis service and we can't guarantee you'll get a reply, so if you need to talk nowClick here for help
The current time is Wed, 5:11 AM
(Australian Eastern time)
It looks like you’re visiting us from a country other than Australia.
We are an Australian service and think you’d benefit more from looking up a similar service in your country.
You are welcome to look around the forums, but please don’t make an account or post, as we can’t offer you the help you may need.
Before you go ahead and post, you should know that we remove non-Australian accounts – not because we don’t want to help or connect with you, but because we may not be able to provide you with the service that you require.